>>17013
>pretty sure thats already an agreed upon standard
Well I lumped booru categories in with namespaces because I consider them analogous de facto in that they serve the same purpose and de jure given that importers treat them as such. So yeah, on the PTR? Yeah. I don't know any boorus using it however. character:person is usually used which I think is bad practice due to searchability reasons. Though hydrus norms being more advanced than booru norms is a fairly noncontrovertial assertion around here. :^)
>oh disregard, i didnt realize you meant drawn for an event and not a depiction of an event with your christmas example
Well, like I said any good namespace should have several usecases rolled up into it in my opinion. If it were just christmas and new years etc. I'd actually agree with your initial point (for reasons that will soon become logically apparent). But since there are so many things it CAN be used on, that are pointedly different and purposeful... that if you're going to implement it for specific events (pixivsnow, cirno day, comiket2019, girls fronline 2 art contest FA 2024, etc.) you might as well extend the umbrella to its fullest while you're implementing it and move christmas from series: to a much more logical place now that it exists in this framework. But I believe you understand that having read the reply now, yeah.
>>17012
>my personal shitty namespace no one else uses is outfit. "outfit:maid" clarifies that the wearer may not really be a maid.
See our thinking merges and clashes here. We agree there is a line past which bluetags exist for a reason but disagree on what is useful to know at a glance by colour. Generic costumes are an ideal blue tag merely for searching, character costumes go in the character space. We already know Hong Meiling isn't a maid inherently if we know who she is, if she's dressed up like one she's merely in an [alternate costume], [maid_uniform] as opposed to a [maid] proper. Anybody who didn't already know this could glean it from how we tagged it this way. Hairstyles, costumes, jewelry, these are descriptive and per hydev "tags are for searching not describing", to the extent you want to search these differences out to post them I understand (I have an inordinate amount of images of hong meiling being dressed up like a maid by/for/like sakuya myself, as well as images of sakuya with really long hair) but I don't see an argument to be a namespace with its own colour and subsequent popout effect. I will add a second aphorism purely of my own "namespaces are for user recognition not categorising", that is we make the spaces to block off relevant info either for human readable tag context or for the human user to pick between search results quickly via colour.
>pic related
The namespacing specifically lets what I'm looking for be searched with fewer typed characters then a click of colour recognition. So the rubric (to me) for if something belongs namespaced or not is "for the bulk of people/the maintainer is it useful to know with a single glance a unique category of image when browsing or searching?". Even if we "extend the umbrella" and include character outfits from gacha games or arc clothing changes for anime/manga that do that a la one piece (Nico Robins Thriller Bark look is still my favourite for the record) how often does somebody searching need a clear colour barrier to differentiate that when searching? Or needs that to pop out when looking at tags? In my example "scarlet" I have so many results it's very very nice to have a clear colour barrier. So, relevant to that, would you ever need to see a hypthetical [costume:Pure White That Will Be Stained Scarlet] (remilia's oath skin in touhou lost word) from the other [character:remilia scarlet], [group:scarlet devil mansion], [creator:chiren_scarlet], [event:remilia scarlet's trick or bullet] and all the [title:something something scarlet] in a search or tag summary quickly?
Your points are good but apply to tags broadly, not namespaces specifically. Which, to me, exist for readability. To go after the underpinnings of the namespace itself does [outfit:Pure White That Will Be Stained Scarlet] make any sense outside of the context of [character:remilia scarlet] such that [character:Remilia Scarlet (Pure White That Will Be Stained Scarlet)] doesn't work better? If an arc costume change why not [character:Nico Robin (Thriller Bark)]? If a generic outfit, why can't a costume be a mere blue search term? [nurse_uniform], [alternate_costume] covers this entirely. Is there a case where it being a new colour in hydrus or colour/category on a booru would be useful to your immediate recognition of [outfit:Dirty Clothes] from say [series:Dirty Pair] and [character:Dirty Harry] upon typing "dirty"?
These aren't retorical or argumentative questions, mind you. You seem to use this system so I'd be interested to hear your opinion given my expounded logical framework and reasoning. I told you I fucking LOVE me some tagtism.